Myth vs fact · Period Care

Are organic tampons safer? What the metals study found

Not for metals: in a 2024 study, organic tampons had more arsenic, not less, and the FDA later found almost none of the metals leach out.

A 2024 study found metals in tampons, organic ones included. A 2026 FDA study then found that almost none of it leaches out.

Myth

Organic tampons are free of metals.

Fact

Organic tampons had more arsenic in the 2024 study, and the FDA found the metals barely leach out.

What the 2024 study measured

  • 16metals measured
  • 30tampons tested
  • 14brands

FDA follow-up, 2026How much leaches out: “negligible”. Source 2

What’s in a tampon isn’t the same as what reaches your body. Study figures as reported Source 1

Is there lead in tampons?

A 2024 study found some in every tampon it tested. Researchers measured 16 metals in 30 tampons from 14 brands, and lead turned up in all of them, organic ones included. The organic tampons had more arsenic, not less. Source 1

What did the FDA’s 2026 study find?

That almost none of it leaches out: the FDA tested how much gets out of a tampon and called the amount “negligible”. Source 2 The 2024 study had measured what’s in a tampon, not what gets into your body.

So “organic” doesn’t fix metals. Organic cotton avoids pesticide residue and fragrance, which is a different question.

What can you use instead?

A silicone cup is reusable and cuts waste.

Most people take a few cycles to get comfortable, so wear a liner at first. Rare but serious: cups and tampons have both been linked to toxic shock syndrome. Follow the maker’s wear time. For tampons, use the lowest absorbency you need. Take it out and get medical help right away if you get a sudden fever, vomiting or diarrhea, a sunburn-like rash, or dizziness. The cup is silicone. There’s no well-rated natural-rubber cup yet. Organic tampons had more arsenic, not less, and period underwear has its own PFAS lawsuits.

Sources (2)
  1. Shearston et al. 2024, Environment International: metals measured in 30 tampons (opens in a new tab)
  2. FDA 2026, Toxicological Sciences: leaching ‘negligible’ (opens in a new tab)

More myths, checked

All 13 myths

Tap one to see what the sources actually say.